A single photograph may attest to my visit, yet I refrain from sharing more lest I mislead. Huangling, alas, is a contrived tourist attraction, with roadside shops abounding and only a couple of structures retaining a semblance of traditional Hui-style architecture. The autumn harvest display, meant to captivate with its visual splendor, lacks any authentic flavor or local charm. Crowds gather before piles of pumpkins, eager for a photo op, yet the scenery lacks captivating beauty amidst the sea of colorful signboards. Ironically, it is the unassuming alleyways that steal the show with their unpretentious charm.
The journey is a relentless climb, uphill and up stairs, with shops lining the roadside, resembling a rural version of Nanluoguxiang, Pingjiang Road, or Tianzifang. The talk of Hui-style architecture is misplaced here; one would be better served seeking out authentic Hui complexes. Some may argue about the authenticity of original Hui architecture, but the essence is not in evicting residents and filling the spaces with shops. Places like Huizhou Ancient City, Yangchan Tulou, and Li Hongzhang’s former residence all bear the rich cultural heritage of Hui architecture.
Comparisons to the Forbidden City are misplaced; the latter retains its historical grandeur without succumbing to commercialization. If not self-driving, the inconvenience of transportation is immense. The journey between Huangling, Wuyuan, and Wangxian Valley is an hourlong ordeal, even with our own vehicle, as we were forced to walk the final stretch. Wangxian Valley is no exception, offering a manufactured version of Nanluoguxiang, followed by a climb to a food street devoid of scenic views. Instead, it’s a conglomeration of shops and bars, a far cry from the natural wonders one might hope for.
Huangshan boasts breathtaking natural landscapes, but Wangxian Valley falls short. If one’s sole purpose is to admire the evening lights, then perhaps it suffices. However, the accommodation and transportation infrastructure leave much to be desired, with winding mountain roads, limited dining options, and even the better-equipped guesthouses lacking sound insulation. The lack of inspiring scenery, regardless of crowd size, is a testament to the over-commercialization that has eroded the authenticity of these places.
Travel goals and preferences vary, and I personally cherish the opportunity to witness the natural beauty and cultural nuances of different regions. While a visit to Suzhou’s Zhuozheng Garden, despite the crowds, offers a glimpse of the unparalleled beauty of Chinese gardens, I understand that others may seek different experiences. Some may find satisfaction in capturing photogenic moments, even if it means enduring the hustle and bustle of photo ops. Nevertheless, for those seeking a more authentic and enriching travel experience, it’s advisable to steer clear of over-commercialized destinations like Huangling and Wangxian Valley.
